Current Price: ~$27.40 | 52-Week High: $87.30 | Reiterate Buy 27.90 (DD)
The Two-Phase Collapse (January–February 2026)
Upstart’s decline from the $38 range to its 52-week low of $27.04 on February 23 was not one event — it was two distinct selloffs, stacked on top of each other, and the second one is where market misidentification created your opportunity.
Phase 1 — February 11 (Earnings Reaction): UPST dropped 13.5% in a single session following Q4 earnings. The selloff was triggered by a CEO transition announcement (Dave Girouard stepping down in May, replaced by co-founder Paul Gu), an EPS miss ($0.17 actual vs. $0.46 expected), and near-term margin compression guidance driven by Upstart’s deliberate pivot into secured auto and home equity products. Importantly, the top-line actually beat — $296M vs. $288M expected, up 35% year-over-year, with loan originations surging 86%. The market punished guidance optics, not business performance.
Phase 2 — February 19 Onward (The Blue Owl Contagion): You are exactly right. On February 19, Blue Owl Capital (OWL) announced it was permanently halting quarterly redemptions on OBDC II, its $1.6 billion retail-facing private credit fund, while simultaneously executing a $1.4 billion loan asset fire sale across three funds. The reaction was immediate and indiscriminate. Blue Owl fell 10%, Blackstone dropped 5–6%, Apollo slid 6%, and the contagion swept through anything perceived to touch credit markets. UPST, already wounded from the earnings reaction, got caught in the blast radius. Upstart hit a 52-week low of $29.61 on February 19 — the same day the Blue Owl news broke — and has continued sliding, touching $27.04 on February 23.
Mohamed El-Erian called Blue Owl a “canary in the coal mine,” Senator Warren declared it evidence of rot in the shadow banking system, and retail investors panicked across the entire credit complex. Upstart got dragged along.
Why the Association Is Fundamentally Wrong
Blue Owl’s crisis is a liquidity mismatch problem in private middle-market corporate debt — illiquid long-duration loans packaged into vehicles that promised semi-liquid retail redemptions. That is not Upstart’s business model. Not even close.
Upstart is an AI technology platform that earns transaction fees when banks and credit unions originate consumer loans through its system. It does not run a credit fund. It does not hold long-dated illiquid paper in a retail wrapper. It does not gate redemptions because there are no redemptions to gate. Its 91% autonomous loan decisioning means it is increasingly a pure SaaS-style platform sitting above the lending system, not inside it. The Blue Owl episode exposed the central tension in private credit between illiquid assets and liquidity demands — a tension that is structurally irrelevant to Upstart’s business.
The market is conflating “credit-adjacent” with “credit-impaired.” Upstart’s risk is consumer credit deterioration affecting loan volumes — a real risk, but one its own AI models actively manage in real time and one that management stated showed no fundamental cracks in their underwriting performance.
Why This Is a Buy
The bull case hasn’t weakened — it has gotten cheaper:
Fundamentals hold up. Q4 revenue grew 35%, originations jumped 86%, full-year 2025 revenue hit $1.04 billion (up 64% from 2024), and adjusted EBITDA came in at $230M with a 22% margin. Management is guiding for $1.4 billion in 2026 revenue and a 35% CAGR through 2028.
Smart money is accumulating. Hidden Lake loaded 316,000 shares worth $13.8 million in February. More critically, on February 20 — the day after the Blue Owl panic — Upstart announced an inaugural 12-month forward-flow deal for Wafra-managed funds to buy up to $200 million of assets originated through Upstart’s auto finance platform. Capital partners are not running away. Management also announced a $100 million share repurchase — a direct signal of confidence at these levels.
Analysts remain constructive. The Wall Street consensus price target is $51–56, representing 85–100%+ upside from current prices. Even Goldman Sachs, a prior Sell-rater, upgraded to Neutral. The analyst breakdown sits at 7 Buys, 6 Holds, 2 Sells — net bullish with significant room to reaccelerate.
Valuation. At ~$27.40, UPST trades at a forward P/S of roughly 1.9x on $1.4B guided revenue with a $2.6B market cap. For a company with 35% guided CAGR and 81% gross margins, that is deeply discounted.
The Trade
The Blue Owl private credit crisis is real — but it is a structural problem in illiquid corporate middle-market debt vehicles sold to retail investors, not an indictment of AI consumer lending technology platforms. The market is selling the wrong thing. Upstart’s 52-week low near $27 is a sentiment-driven dislocation, not a fundamental one. The business is executing, new capital partners are signing on, and management is buying back stock at the lows.
UPST is a buy at current levels. The risk is that consumer credit broadly deteriorates faster than Upstart’s models can adapt — but the reward at these prices could pay off significantly like the last time I recommended UPST. UPST is only for investors who handle a significant risk.
🔒 Disclaimer & Disclosure Statement
IMPORTANT – READ CAREFULLY:
The content provided in this newsletter (hereafter referred to as “the Newsletter”) is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, financial advice, trading advice, or any other form of personal or professional advice. You should not rely solely on the information provided herein to make investment decisions.
Business Structure and Professional Status
This Newsletter is published by a publishing and content company engaged in the business of providing financial commentary, market analysis, and educational content. I am not a licensed financial advisor, investment advisor, broker-dealer, or registered representative. While I was previously a licensed stockbroker for over 25 years, I currently hold no active securities licenses or professional financial designations. My opinions are solely my own and reflect my personal market views and trading activity. I frequently hold positions in the securities I discuss and may buy or sell shares at any time, including before or after publication. Any such ownership will be disclosed, but this does not constitute a recommendation for you to act similarly. My positions may create actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
Regulatory Status
This Newsletter is not subject to oversight by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or any other regulatory body, as I am not a registered investment advisor or broker-dealer. The Newsletter operates outside the regulatory framework that governs registered financial professionals.
No Fiduciary Duty
I have no fiduciary duty to any reader or subscriber of this Newsletter. The information provided is general in nature and is not tailored to the investment objectives, financial situation, or risk profile of any individual.
Not a Solicitation
This Newsletter is not a solicitation to buy or sell any security. Any mention of a security, company, or financial instrument is for illustrative and commentary purposes only.
Forward-Looking Statements and Projections
All forward-looking statements, market predictions, price targets, and financial projections are based on assumptions, current expectations, and available information, and are subject to risks, uncertainties, and changes without notice. Such statements are highly speculative in nature and should not be relied upon as factual representations of future events. Market conditions can change rapidly and unpredictably. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Compensation and Independence
As a publishing and content company, I receive no compensation from any company, issuer, or third party for the securities I discuss. My only compensation comes from paid subscriptions to this Newsletter and other content-related business activities.
Investment Risks
Investing in stocks and other securities involves substantial risk, including the risk of loss of capital. You are solely responsible for your own investment decisions. You should consult with a licensed financial advisor, tax professional, and/or attorney before making any investment or financial decisions.
Information Sources and Accuracy
The content in this Newsletter is provided “as is” without any warranties or guarantees, expressed or implied. No representation is made as to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of any information contained herein. While I strive for accuracy, information obtained from third-party sources, including company reports, news services, and market data providers, may contain errors or omissions for which I cannot be held responsible. All content is subject to change without notice.
Geographic Limitations
This Newsletter is intended primarily for residents of the United States and is prepared in accordance with U.S. securities laws and regulations. International readers should consult with local legal and financial professionals to ensure compliance with applicable laws in their jurisdiction before acting on any information contained herein.
Technology and Delivery Risks
Electronic delivery of the Newsletter may be subject to technical failures, delays, or interruptions beyond our control. While we strive for reliable delivery, we cannot guarantee the timeliness or successful delivery of all communications.
Subscription Terms
This Newsletter and its contents are intended solely for the personal use of paid subscribers and may not be redistributed, reproduced, forwarded, or republished in any form without the publisher’s prior written consent. Subscription cancellation and refund policies, if any, are governed by separate terms of service.
Legal Compliance and Official Filings
All readers are strongly encouraged to review official company filings, including those available at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) website, and to conduct independent research before making any investment decisions.
Indemnification
You agree to indemnify and hold harmless the publisher, its affiliates, contributors, and employees from any and all liability, loss, or damages that may arise directly or indirectly from your use of the Newsletter.
By reading or subscribing to this Newsletter, you acknowledge that you have read, understood, and agree to be bound by all terms of this disclaimer.